The condition we'd concede on.
Kinbase is a specification and an experiment, not yet a product. Until the experiment passes, everything above is intent.
Eleven arms run on the same brownfield commits, with the same model, tools, and budget, scored by people who cannot see which arm produced what. Two conditions carry the claim. The rest keep us honest about why it worked.
01Match an agent that was handed the full spec.
Blind scorers compare the full system with an agent given the fully informed spec on the same commit. It must score at least 0.90 and land within 0.05 of that agent, close at least 70% of the gap between a plain agent and the spec-fed one, and beat the plain agent by 0.15. If it doesn't, we say so.
02Zero seeded secrets reach a shared surface.
Thirty or more planted secrets and identifiers, across every kind of evidence, including under prompt-injection and indirect-identifier probes. One reaching a shared candidate or surface is a failed proof. This one is a correctness property, not a target.
- knowledge, not plumbing
- Beat the same hooks and scaffolding running on an empty corpus by 0.15. Beat a 2 KiB conventions note and plain top-k retrieval by 0.10.
- routing
- Sort what it learns into the right store at 0.90 macro-F1 or better, with 0.95 precision or better on anything shared, across five recorded live-model runs. Roughly: fewer than one in twenty shared items misfiled.
- approval fatigue
- At most four shared approval prompts an hour, never three in a row without returning you to your work. A blinded twenty-item operator test must be 95% correct at a median of 30 seconds. Failing this is not proven, even if privacy passes.
- the right fact, in context
- In at least 80% of dependent edits, the load-bearing fact is present with a mean of at most 12 facts per projection.
- blinding
- Scorers also guess which arm made each output. If they can, the run is void.
- evidence
- At least seven kinds ingested end to end, including Codex and Claude Code transcripts, git history, code, tests, and the repository's .kin/.